The white elephant gift exchange has at least 25 names because the game spread by word of mouth and each region named it for the feature it liked best: swapping (Yankee Swap), stealing (Dirty Santa, Thieving Elves), dice (Rob Your Neighbor), or the gift pile (white elephant). The basic game is the same everywhere.
Why so many names?
The game spread by word of mouth — family to family, break room to break room — and every region named it after the feature it liked best: the swapping (Yankee Swap), the stealing (Dirty Santa, Thieving Elves), the dice (Rob Your Neighbor), or the gift pile itself (white elephant). Same skeleton everywhere: bring a wrapped gift, draw numbers, unwrap or steal, freeze at three. Here's the full map.
Regional names you'll actually hear
| Name | Where it's used | What's different about it |
|---|---|---|
| White Elephant | Nationwide default; office standard | Mixed gift pools; the rules most sites document |
| Yankee Swap | New England & Northeast | Desirable gifts; "swap" framing; 2–3 swaps then frozen |
| Dirty Santa | The American South | Steal-forward; often looser or unlimited steal caps |
| Pollyanna | Parts of Pennsylvania & New Jersey (disputed) | Named for the 1913 optimist heroine. Some groups use it for this stealing game; others mean a Secret Santa–style draw with no stealing, so confirm before you plan. |
| Rob Your Neighbor | Midwest | Frequently dice- or card-driven; whole-circle passing |
| Left-Right Game / Pass the Parcel | Nationwide, kids & classrooms | Different mechanic: story cues pass gifts; no stealing |
| Chinese Gift Exchange | Canada & parts of the U.S. | Another name for the same game; the name has no real connection to Chinese culture |
| Chinese Auction | NY/PA fundraisers (a raffle, not this game) | Different game entirely: tickets and prize draws |
| Thieving Elves / Stealing Santa | Holiday-themed households | Keeps the steal, drops the word "dirty" for mixed company |
| Bad Santa | Gag-gift rule sets | Pool is strictly terrible/thrifted gifts on purpose |
| Cutthroat Christmas | Competitive circles | Unlimited steals, no freeze |
The deeply unofficial aliases
Documented in the wild (Wikipedia's list, gift-exchange compendiums, and party-forum lore) — these circulate wherever the game needs a fresh bit:
| Name | Vibe |
|---|---|
| Shifty Santa | Slightly embarrassed about the whole affair |
| The Grinch Game | Leans into the theft, family-safe wording |
| Thieves' Christmas | The whole holiday, rebranded |
| Steal-a-Thon | For groups that time their steal chains |
| Greedy Punter | Spotted in UK/Antipodean corners of the internet |
| Kamikaze Gift Exchange | No strategy, all collision |
| Machiavellian Christmas | For the group that forms alliances |
| Snatchy Christmas Rat | Affectionate, allegedly |
| Naughty Santa / Black Santa / Redneck Santa | Regional flavor variants on the steal theme |
| Thieving Secret Santa / Bastard Secret Santa | Secret Santa that betrayed its own premise |
| Yanky Swap | Variant spelling seen in the UK and NZ |
Which name should your invitation use?
Use the name your room already knows — it sets expectations better than any rules paragraph. Say "Yankee Swap" and New Englanders bring gifts worth stealing; say "Bad Santa" and they'll bring a half-used candle with a scratcher taped inside (a real and glorious submission from the field). Say "white elephant" anywhere and almost everyone knows the shape of the night. For rules that work under any alias, head to the rulebook.
Pick a name. Print the rules. Bring the Bailey's.
The complete step-by-step rules work for every name on this page — including the freeze, steal-backs, and Player 1's revenge.
Read the full rules →Names FAQ
What's another name for a white elephant gift exchange?
Yankee Swap (New England), Dirty Santa (the South), Pollyanna (PA/NJ, where it often means a Secret Santa–style draw), and Rob Your Neighbor (Midwest) are the big four. Dozens more circulate: Thieving Elves, Shifty Santa, the Grinch Game, Cutthroat Christmas, Steal-a-Thon, and friends.
Are all these names the same game?
Mechanically yes — numbered turns, unwrap or steal, freeze rules. The names differ mainly by region and gift-pool expectations.
What is "Pollyanna"? I thought that was a movie.
Pollyanna (1913 novel, then films) is also a gift-exchange name in parts of Pennsylvania and New Jersey, but usage is disputed. Some groups use it for the white elephant stealing game; others mean a Secret Santa–style draw with no stealing. Ask your group which game it means.
What's the Left-Right game?
A different mechanic where gifts pass around a circle as a story is read aloud with "left" and "right" cues — no stealing at all, but hosts often use the name interchangeably for casual swaps.
Sources and notes
Sources reviewed November 2026.
- WhiteElephantRules.com: The Many Other Names for White Elephant: Lists regional and alternative names, including Dirty Santa, Yankee Swap and Pollyanna.
- Mental Floss: Rules and Origins of 6 Gift Exchanges: Origins and regional popularity of Yankee Swap, Dirty Santa and Pollyanna.
- Elfster: Gift Exchange Rules: Describes “Rob Your Neighbor” as the inherited term in some Midwest families and offices.
- Project Gutenberg: Pollyanna by Eleanor H. Porter: The 1913 novel that the name “Pollyanna” refers to.
Note on “Pollyanna”: sources disagree. Some list it as a white elephant name in parts of Pennsylvania and New Jersey; others, including Elfster and SecretSanta.com, say that in the same region it means a Secret Santa–style draw with no stealing. Ask your group which game it means before you plan around it.